Friday, October 14, 2005

Eruvin: The Private Domain

KEY TERMS AS DEFINED BY ARTSCROLL. CHATZEIR = courtyard. KORAH = a crossbeam, at least one tefach wide, reaching across a mavoi to serve as a rudimentary partition or a reminder of a mavoi's halachic status. MAVOI = alley; specifically an alley into which chatzeiros open. SUCCAH = temporary dwelling used during the festival of Succos.

As I begin to study this Tractate, which is concerned with the rules of transferring objects from one domain to another, I also am beginning to experience the effect of transfers that violate personal boundaries: nearly every day recently, anonymous contributors have posted to this blog, probably with the aid of some kind of robot, notices promoting their own blogs for life in the southwest, liability insurance, or sexual aids. And while all of these notices begin with some positive statement such as "You sure have a cool blog!", these are not readers, these are people from outside the chatzeir trying to sneak into my mavoi.

On the one hand, the only way to keep my space clear is to be my own gatekeeper; to review each submission as it arrives and refuse delivery of inappropriate submissions before you have a chance to see them. On the other hand, if I don't leave an opening through which you can easily enter, I may never see your best thoughts and questions. It is the same dilemma faced on 3a of this tractate. If ownership is shared, the integrity of the roof and entrance may be compromised more than if ownership is held by an individual: "Since a Succah is meant for the use of an individual, rather than of the public, he realizes his responsibility for it and is mindful of its condition. But in the case of a mavoi, which is meant for the public to use, they each rely on each other and they are not mindful of the korah's condition. For as people say: 'A pot in the charge of two cooks is neither hot nor cold'-- i.e., each one relies on the other one to do the necessary work, which as a result never gets done."


Not in Heaven

The Gemara executes a very interesting two-step after putting forward the Baraisa that "One who wishes to act in accordance with Beis Shammai's views may do so" (6b). It asks, how can this be? After all, a Heavenly voice had declared that the Halachah always follows Beis Hillel. Perhaps, it suggests, that this Baraisa dates from before the Heavenly voice? Or perhaps this teaching is the view of R'Yehoshua,"who pays no heed to heavenly voices" (7a).

This lack of respect for Heavenly voices derives from the famous incident of the oven in Bava Metzia (59b), where R'Eliezer's miraculous proofs are all overruled by the very same R'Yehoshua (who cites Scripture to prove that the Torah is "not in Heaven"). ArtScroll's review of the commentaries notes that the difference between the Heavenly declarations in the two cases is that in R'Eliezer's account the Heavenly voice is going against the majority while in Beis Hillel's account it is confirming the will of the majority.

This is part of a discussion in which the explicit question is whether to be lenient or stringent in determining practice; and what to do if two stringencies (or two leniencies) inherently contradict each other. The bottom line is that one should pick one teacher and follow all his rulings. This is good advice but, of course, not easy advice to follow amidst the uncertainty as to who taught what and in which context!

The Gemara accentuates the difficulty by (perhaps mischievously) following the teaching to pick one teacher by two instances of references to multiple rabbis with the same name. On 8b, "Rav Kahana bar Tachlifa cited the following ruling in the name of Rav Kahana bar Manyumi who cited it in the name of Rav Kahana the teacher of Rav . . ." and then "Rav Kahana said . . . 'I, whose name is also Kahana will say something about it. . ." Thus, chosing to follow "Rav Kahana" may lead to the question "Who's on first?"

32 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

Great Blog! Ilike it.I have Site where you can Find sex partnerTake a look if you have a minute. Thanks and have a good one!

6:52 AM  
Anonymous Reed Chopper said...

Another spammer has snuck into your mavoi.

The bottom line is that one should pick one teacher and follow all his rulings.

This strategy is honored in the frum community big time ("I hold by Rabbi X"), and avoids the hypocrisy of picking and choosing authorities for individual specific questions based on how you know they are going to rule. I don't like the idea of following one authority in all things it because it seems to me to be an abrogation of responsibility to think for oneself. It's also wussy, because if it turns out to be the wrong call, hey, it's not on your head.

An important difference between me and them is that they think that in every instance there is a right and wrong call: G?d knows whether sturgeon really is or isn't kosher, and we had better not guess wrong. My view is that either call makes sense (the mature fish lacks scales is the issue).

The Gemara accentuates the difficulty by (perhaps mischievously) following the teaching to pick one teacher by two instances of references to multiple rabbis with the same name. On 8b, "Rav Kahana bar Tachlifa cited the following ruling in the name of Rav Kahana bar Manyumi who cited it in the name of Rav Kahana the teacher of Rav . . ." and then "Rav Kahana said . . . 'I, whose name is also Kahana will say something about it. . ." Thus, chosing to follow "Rav Kahana" may lead to the question "Who's on first?"

Rav Kahana told me that his uncle, after whom he was named, is on first.

3:30 PM  
Blogger Greg said...

Hi,

you really have a very nice blog here! I'm definitely going to bookmark you!

I have a site dealing with affordable seo. You are heartly invited to take some really good tips from it.



Come and check it out if you get time :-)

TheSEO-Rank.com

12:57 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Wow, I really like this one. I have a website that talks mostly about company diego san seo You should check it out sometime.

1:22 AM  
Blogger eLearning at Resource Bridge said...

We are a website hosting company. Trying to get links is a nightmare for this particular keyword. Can someone please tell us why if we have over 500 links inbound to our site, that only 57 show up in Google? I checked the PR on the sites. Some are 5 some are 3 etc. There seems to be no rhyme or reason to it. We try to only have relevent links to our site, but, old links appear in Google.

Any idea's?

Thanks much!**hosting**

11:18 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

nice blog enjoyed it :)

Keep up the excellent work! and i bookmarked u!

so cant wait for ur next post! :)

Thanks!!

11:36 PM  
Anonymous increase semen said...

Your Blog. It's nice . If you ever need penis enlargement related stuff, I'm sure you'd be interested in penis enlargement.

6:11 AM  
Anonymous penis enlargement said...

This is a excellent blog. Keep it going. I found you while searching for harder erection. I have a site on harder erection located here, harder erection Maybe you can stop by sometime.

9:50 AM  
Anonymous male ejaculation said...

Bloggs are such a wonderful way to plublish ones thoughts. Thanks for letting me visit and leave a comment. Love the title, "this post" Come by my site some time. It's got male ejaculation related stuff.

8:33 PM  
Anonymous Hypno Porn said...

NeilLitt great blog! Glad I found it! After looking at your this post I will definitely be back again! Sex Pics

6:37 AM  
Anonymous increase semen production said...

What a great site you have here, I bookmarked it! I was looking for this post or something like it. Very informative.

I have a increase semen related site.

Check it out when you can. ;)

9:40 PM  
Blogger Chlora said...

NeilLitt great blog! Glad I found it! After looking at your this post I will definitely be back again! Drunk Girls

7:09 AM  
Blogger Chlora said...

NeilLitt great blog! Glad I found it! After looking at your this post I will definitely be back again! orgies

8:17 AM  
Blogger Bud Wiser said...

NeilLitt, Nice blog, really enjoyed it, will be back for sure! I'm always looking for interesting related sites to Amateur Wives that I can link from my page Amateur Wiveshttp://www.heather-friends.com

3:07 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hey, you have a great blog here! I'm definitely going to bookmark you!

I have a crazy shirtholden t-shirt site called Holden Tees. We're a small company and we sell shirts and stuff.

Come and check it out if you get time

-Holden Tees

9:46 AM  
Blogger Chlora said...

NeilLitt great blog! Glad I found it! After looking at your this post I will definitely be back again! Drunk Girls

1:11 AM  
Blogger Chlora said...

NeilLitt great blog! Glad I found it! After looking at your this post I will definitely be back again! orgies

6:28 AM  
Anonymous semen volume increase said...

Your blog is creative Keep up the great work. Maybe you could stop by my site sometime here: increase ejaculate

4:24 PM  
Blogger FEVPEICP said...

On the same subject line, it's interesting how many people look for information about semen volume pill . I also like learning more about semen volume pill One of the sites I find very informative is semen volume pill I've learned alot from them.

9:40 AM  
Anonymous Penis said...

On the same subject line, it's interesting how many people look for information about small penis photographs . I also like learning more about small penis photographs One of the sites I find very informative is small penis photographs I've learned alot from them.

2:08 PM  
Blogger BKPKQKYF said...

A fantastic blog. Keep it up. I have a site that might be of interested to you if you are seeking how to stimulate the body to produce more semen related items. You can find it here, how to stimulate the body to produce more semen

2:27 PM  
Blogger XFQKTNTK said...

What a great site you have here, I bookmarked it! I was looking for semen volume or something like it. Very informative.

I have a semen volume related site.

Check it out when you can. ;)

11:11 AM  
Blogger XSFPODDJ said...

I've got a new site up which might to be of interest to some. I run a increase semen your related site.
Alot of interesting comments on this blog, I was searching for increase semen your related info and some how came across this site. I found it pretty cool, so I bookmarked. I'll really theme, that got my attention.

4:25 PM  
Blogger DPORXXVW said...

This is a excellent blog. Keep it going. When searching for circumference produce more semen, I happened to come across your site. I'll bookmark it. Perhaps you would be interested in my site, circumference produce more semen

10:29 PM  
Blogger FEVPEICP said...

I'm always on the lookout for other people interested in teens ejaculate. Glad I found you. Another site I would recommend on the subject is teens ejaculate Happy Day.

3:23 AM  
Blogger Scott said...

This is a excellent blog. Keep it going. When searching for high semen volume, I happened to come across your site. I'll bookmark it. Perhaps you would be interested in my site, high semen volume

2:33 PM  
Blogger blog000111 said...

A lot of interest for your blog and a great deal of discussion. Great sites to surf domain host, domain name, domain reseller, au domain, free website, online business, home based business, electric scooter, xbox360!

8:02 PM  
Anonymous Penis said...

I have a similar site connected to erection man Come by some time.
I with out a doubt like your site, will book mark it! This post is fine stuff.

4:48 AM  
Blogger blog000111 said...

A lot of interest for your blog and a great deal of discussion. Great sites to surf domain web hosting, domain name, domain reseller, au domain, free website, online business, home based business, electric scooter, xbox360!

10:15 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

penis enlargement I have found a proven method anyone can implement to very easily enlarge their penis in very little time and effort. I've been able to create a significant gain in size and girth. This product is the most effective I've found online. People just like you getting the gains they want with very little effort. Stop worrying about a small penis, low confidence, never leave your mate unsatisfied again, and start living your life the way YOU choose with a bigger, harder, and wider member! - Please visit penis enlargement

11:40 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Very cool design! Useful information. Go on!
Buy en language tamiflu Moisture tamiflu Psychiatry buspirone Best hockey goal ever highlights id software Emerald passport business opportunity African american scholarship fund Buy dedicated server by discover New rider truck rental

3:22 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hi,
I found your blog via google by accident and have to admit that youve a really interesting blog :-)
Just saved your feed in my reader, have a nice day :)

2:33 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home