Saturday, July 10, 2010

Head versus Heart

I have been reading Richard A. Posner’s How Judges Think. Posner notes that a judge’s response to a case “is generated by legal doctrine, institutional constraints, policy preferences, strategic considerations, and the equities of the case, all mixed together and all mediated by temperament, experience, ambition, and other personal factors.” Thus, personal predilections foster both a Judge Shammai (focused on legal doctrine and institutional constraints) and a Judge Hillel (tilting toward policy preferences and concerned with the equity of the case).

Whether judges “think” at all is no more certain than whether you or I do. It has been suggested that our opinions may be more emotional reactions than intellectual conclusions. In an article in tomorrow’s NY Times Magazine, Judith Werner cites Richard Hofstadter’s classic Anti-Intellectualism in American Life wherein he wrote that ‘Intellect is pitted against feeling . . . [and] against character, because it is widely believed that intellect stands for mere cleverness, which transmutes easily into the sly or diabolical.” In Warner’s article, whether or not judges think is not the point; the point is that judges facing senate confirmation hearings are cautioned not to risk “intellectually outshining the senators” (in other words, don’t let them see you think).

As this blog is at least ostensibly intended to focus on Jewish thought and/or Talmudic distinctions and processes, I will digress momentarily. The aforementioned Hofstadter is from the generation of Jews (on his father’s side) who were raised by parents for whom English was most certainly not their first language. Like my favorite non-Jewish "Jewish" straight man Bud Abbott, Hofstadter had one Jewish parent but was raised as a Lutheran.

In the 1940s, my English teacher, Alfred Kazin, often sat next to him in the great reading room of the 42nd Street Library. In Kazin’s journal, he wrote of Hofstadter, “His German-background Lutheran mother had died early; his Polish-Jewish father had given his gift for Yiddish an irresistible turn. Between two such worlds--who would have guessed that the middle name of this former Lutheran altar boy was Irving?--he had become the amused outsider who looked Gentile, was married to a Jew, and whose friends were regularly Jews.”

Another entry in Kazin’s journal on Hofstadter’s wife, Felice, will get me back to my main subject today-- head versus heart. Felice was one of the first women to be accorded the status of writer (as opposed to researcher at Time Magazine: “Felice loved being important to Time more than she could ever love Time itself. Writing up a frightful industrial accident in which a worker had been pressed to death by a machine, she had thought it clever to write that the victim could now be slipped under the door. On her way home she felt horrified by her callousness, rushed back to the office to change the piece, and found the managing editor roundly congratulating her.” Here indeed is an apt example of the heartlessness of clever wit that is associated with the moral bankruptcy of intellect. Anti-intellectualism may be America’s reaction to the Enlightenment, but many of us are so well educated that we are both for it and against it.

A recent current event illustrates the quandary. The decision by the United States District Court in Boston on Thursday essentially nullified the Federal Defense of Marriage Act and affirmed the right of the state of Massachusetts to guarantee rights to same-sex couples. What combination of “legal doctrine, institutional constraints, policy preferences, strategic considerations, and the equities of the case” led to this decision? As Kirk Johnson points out in today’s NY Times, the ruling affirms states’ rights and limits the authority of the federal government (if it is upheld). As such, it should be applauded by those whose primary agenda is to limit the power of the federal government. Of course, many of these are the same people who also insist on a traditional definition of marriage. The former is an intellectual position and the latter is an emotional response.

Personally, I have never understood why marriage is regarded as a civil matter at all. It has always seemed to me that any state or federal definition of marriage is tantamount to the legislation of a religious tenet that is particular to some but not all denominations of Judaism and Christianity (and probably all Muslims-- at least I am not aware of any Imams who perform same-sex commitment ceremonies). I share this understanding with the Gay rights groups who condemned the persecution of Fundamentalist Mormons for practicing polygamy. (Ironically, we must note that the support was not reciprocated: the polygamists regard any gay relationship as a sure path to eternal damnation.) By this line of reasoning, any definition of marriage must be considered unconstitutional and the state should get out of the business of issuing marriage licenses and focus solely on guaranteeing equal protection under the law to all married couples (or swarms, if we have the stomach to include the Mormon fundamentalists!), regardless of how they came to be united.

In any event, states rights is an unsatisfactory principle on which to hang a campaign to ensure equal treatment under the law. The principle that was last used in arguments to delay the adoption of federal laws to prohibit racial discrimination is not going to be our friend in the long run. But what options were open to the United States District Court in Boston? For this judge, the equity of the case weighed more heavily than the legal doctrine; institutional constraints were perhaps ignored in favor of strategic considerations. It will all undoubtedly end up in the Supreme Court, where an affirmation on the basis of states rights would be a stunning victory for gay rights in Massachusetts and a blow to prospects for a federal guarantee of gay rights. Are there other legal doctrines that permit affirming the decision? Is the court likely to reject the reasoning but not overturn the decision? If they do, will they return the case to Boston to be reargued or overturn the Defense of Marriage Act? Stay tuned to find out how these judges think.

Labels: , , , ,

18 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

I would like to exchange links with your site www.blogger.com
Is this possible?

3:26 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Lovely site, I had not encountered this before in my queries! Carry on with the excellent work!

4:51 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I really liked your article.

4:23 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Библиотека http://sunduchokknig.ru качаем книги здесь

10:04 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

top [url=http://www.001casino.com/]free casino bonus[/url] check the latest [url=http://www.realcazinoz.com/]realcazinoz[/url] unshackled no store bonus at the chief [url=http://www.baywatchcasino.com/]no lay bonus
[/url].

10:45 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

mp3alese gratis http://surveys.questionpro.com/a/TakeSurvey?id=3418773 alesse 28 birth control forum [url=http://archive.org/details/enidbaythur] alesse birth control side effects symptoms[/url] alesse 21 birth control reviews alesse 28 birth control price filmealese gratis 2012
mamoleptino321
ellesse clothing buy online http://www.world66.com/member/alesse_n8wsgvhl00s/ oubli pilule alesse [url=http://surveys.questionpro.com/a/TakeSurvey?id=3418712] alesse generic reviews[/url] alesse generic cost alesso years mp3 juices alesse 28 birth control price

http://www.salmanbookcentre.com/?section=GuestBook http://www.flower-for-you.net/cgi-bin/flw_shfl.cgi?month=6&mday=9%22%3Ehow+Result:+%E2%EE%E7%EC%EE%E6%ED%EE,+%EE%F2%EF%F0%E0%E2%EB%E5%ED%EE;+Result:+%ED%E5+%ED%E0%F8%EB%EE%F1%FC+%F4%EE%F0%EC%FB+%E4%EB%FF+%EE%F2%EF%F0%E0%E2%EA%E8; http://www.e-levators.com/hello-world#comment-743 http://bubupet.ro/?p=564#comment-461 http://geo.strand-kiosk.de/forum/viewthread.php?thread_id=42680

alesso years ft matthew koma download http://surveys.questionpro.com/a/TakeSurvey?id=3418898 alesse birth control pill weight gain [url=http://www.world66.com/member/alesse_v0p6ogeav1e/] emotional side effects of alesse[/url] has alice been discontinued alesse canada pharmacy alesse 28

12:06 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

revision de escapada de acne 101E http://archive.org/details/ridimendesp puede australia [url=http://archive.org/details/compreclafen] tratamiento local del acne de Murad[/url] Fotos de cicatrices de acne picahielos Jeans tienda online tratamiento para las cicatrices del acne en cara
mamoleptino321
terapia de luz azul acne http://surveys.questionpro.com/a/TakeSurvey?id=3428129 cara de acne [url=http://surveys.questionpro.com/a/TakeSurvey?id=3428123] medicamentos de acne quistico[/url] productos de acne de OTC Consejos de piel clara de acne tratamiento casero del acne del adulto

http://www.686.it/inc/exe/forum/index.php?&action=vthread&forum=4&topic=886 http://www.greatamericanequipment.com/message.htm http://operatingsystems.zogz.info/how-to-send-message-to-the-other-computer-in-the-same-network-by-using-cmd-in-windows-vista-home-premium/#comment-103439 http://www.blogger.com/comment.g?blogID=778801797266342692&postID=5867032914930326641&page=1&token=1361543465690&isPopup=true http://656132.guestbook.onetwomax.de/

decoloracion de las cicatrices del acne http://archive.org/details/fsetkadeders eliminacion de cicatrices [url=http://www.everyoneweb.es/acne1989a89] acne inflamacion[/url] Neutrogena piel deshacerse de acne en la espalda acne nuevo comercial

1:19 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Incгedіble рοints. Solіԁ argumentѕ.
Keеp up thе great effort.

Fеel free to suгf to my web page: MintedPoker Bonus

4:15 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

http://www.site.com - [url=http://www.site.com]site[/url] site
site

6:45 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Whаt's up, its nice post about media print, we all be familiar with media is a impressive source of data.

My website - BlackChipPoker Promotions

8:29 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I'm extremely pleased to discover this site. I wanted to thank you for ones time for this particularly wonderful read!! I definitely liked every bit of it and i also have you book marked to check out new information on your blog.

Feel free to visit my webpage projektypolskie.pl/

1:46 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Way cοol! Some very vаlid poіnts! I apρreciatе
you penning this pоst plus the гest of thе website is rеally
good.

Mу web рage: http://dentysta.wroclaw.pl/

4:14 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Pretty section of content. I just stumbled upon your web site and in accession capital to assert
that I get in fact enjoyed account your blog
posts. Any way I will be subscribing to your augment and
even I achievement you access consistently fast.


My site; http://ebuybelize.com/

8:49 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hello, Neat post. There's a problem together with your website in internet explorer, could check this? IE still is the market chief and a huge component to other people will miss your fantastic writing because of this problem.

Take a look at my page: Non Owner Car Insurance

1:20 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I hardly leave responses, but i did some searching and wound up here "Head versus Heart".
And I do have 2 questions for you if you do not mind. Could it
be only me or does it seem like a few of these comments look like they are coming from brain dead folks?
:-P And, if you are posting at other sites, I would like to keep up with everything
new you have to post. Could you list of the complete urls of all your community sites like your Facebook page, twitter feed,
or linkedin profile?

My homepage ... http://www.Cheaphighheels.net/trendy-clothes-for-women/

4:51 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

M [url=http://www.nikekutuja.biz/]ナイキスニーカー[/url] aiKok ZdfLwt NqlQby Flb [url=http://www.nikekutuja.biz/air-jordan空気ヨルダン-c-1.html]air jordan[/url] VduYozDoa Sa [url=http://www.nikekutuja.biz/air-maxエアマックス-c-2.html]air max 95[/url] zZetTnuPso DciEjzIma [url=http://www.nikekutuja.biz/nike-air-force-1ナイキエアフォース-c-4.html]ナイキ エアフォース1[/url] Vtd HxiFjz

Mj [url=http://www.nikekutuja.com/]nike スニーカー[/url] eAiy NpxOst HnxCio AeoU [url=http://www.nikekutuja.com/air-jordan空気ヨルダン-c-1.html]air jordan[/url] wsLzdDdo FshIywBcoM [url=http://www.nikekutuja.com/nike-dunkナイキダンク-c-4.html]nike dunk low[/url] ae UxhXbsPh [url=http://www.nikekutuja.com/air-maxエアマックス-c-2.html]ナイキ エアマoックス[/url] kKhk NsiDhw

Qn [url=http://www.nikekutujp.com/]ナイキスニーカー[/url] aBac UnlEip LccUmh FlyQ [url=http://www.nikekutujp.com/nike-dunkナイキダンク-c-4.html]nike dunk low[/url] cjOvuZky N [url=http://www.nikekutujp.com/nike-air-force-1ナイキエアフォース-c-3.html]nike air force 1[/url] kaVshLazUja [url=http://www.nikekutujp.com/air-jordan空気ヨルダン-c-1.html]nike air jordan[/url] GwmPkbEykTao UxkQna

4:25 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...


Nike shoes women air force ones outlet tattooing guide and tips for tattooing

Tattoo, though an impressive and striking body art, involves a lot of pain on the part of the person who is getting it made.At the same time, he/she is required to gather loads of information, take due precautions while selecting the artist as well as the design and undertake a lot of after-Tattoo care as well.With the popularity of tattoos growing with present times and lots of tattoo parlor being opened, it becomes all the more important for a person to exercise due care before getting a tattoo made.In this context, the following tattooing tips will surely come handy.
Read more on tips for tattooing and [URL=http://www.okay2shoes.net/nikeairjordanairjordan8-c-1_16.html][b]Cheap Retro Jordan[/b][/URL] weight reducing tips and health and lifestyle
Tattooing guide
Get acquainted
Before you get a tattoo made on your body, it is advisable to gather complete information on the tattooing process.You need to be aware of how would the process be undertaken and the amount of pain it is likely to cause.Another aspect that you need to be acquainted with is that the tattoo will be there with you throughout your life, unless and until you undertake the painful and expensive removal process.So, getting a tattoo made at the spur of the moment is not a good idea.It is better to be a bit cautious earlier, than regret later on.
Find a professional
It is very necessary for you to find a professional for getting the tattoo made.While an improperly made tattoo can cause skin allergies and infections, use of infected needles can also lead to fatal diseases like aids.So, make sure that the tattoo parlor you are visiting is hygienic and makes us of disposable needles and fresh ink, nike shoes women air force ones outlet, for every session.To ascertain the authenticity of the artist, you can enquire about his/her association with a professional organization/ group.
Select the design
One of the basic requirements of getting yourself tattooed is the selection of [URL=http://www.okay2shoes.net][b]Cheap Nike Shoes[/b][/URL] the design.If you have one in mind already, nothing can be better.Otherwise, you can make use of the collection of designs that are offered at the tattoo parlor.Going through magazines and browsing the internet can also help you arrive at the perfect tattoo design.Even though your specific design costs a bit more money, it will be worth it, as you will be sporting the tattoo throughout your life.


11:34 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Where are you able to buy PLPD Car Insurance? Because of technologies as well as the rise of the web buying inexpensive PLPD insurance plan is never less complicated. Comparing prices and looking around was once a pain. It all included producing several calls plus speaking with a half dozens of sales reps and insurance firms. Obviously additionally you needed to pay attention to every sales rep place in their particular 2 pennies and make the sales hype. Luckily, instances have changed and also you understand lengthier have to do issues the old-fashioned method. Now you can evaluate quotations as well as buy PLPD auto insurance right from the particular convenience of your home. When it is your own goal to get the least expensive price feasible for PLPD insurance plan I recommend checking the web plus going to an online insurance policy assessment site. These sites can make your daily life simple. They are going to request a person several basic questions like your squat code and the type of automobile you generate. When you have offered this information the particular comparison web site will provide you with a listing of the particular carriers inside your zero program code with all the least expensive rates. After you have refined down your choice you are able to finish your quote with all the provider of the selection and finalize your own buy online or even with a live life consultant. kredyt bez poręczycieli i zaświadczeń What exactly are you currently awaiting? Start keeping these days. If you would like to find out who has the lowest prices in your area select one of the hyperlinks below to see a good insurance plan assessment web site which i personally use. Good luck! To obtain a free of charge quote today simply click this link: on-line

9:31 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home